Best Gardening Shoes in 2022 (Reviews and Comparison)

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you purchase through our links. Please read our full disclosure here.

It is never fun to get mud on your new shoes. Nor is it fun to always have to clean off your running shoes from the dirt in the garden. That is why gardening shoes were made to be used fully in the garden while also preventing injury to feet from gardening tools or branches. 

Share:
top gardening shoes

Plus, these shoes are incredibly sturdy which means they hold up against abuse, wear and tear, mud, and dirt. This article aims to show the best gardening shoes reviews, comparisons, and the verdicts on which shoe is the best for men and which is the best for women.

COMPARISON CHART

Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men's Rubber Garden Boots,Bark/Otter,10 M US

Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men’s Rubber Garden Boots
  • 100% Waterproof
  • 4mm Neoprene Insulation
  • Easy On/Off with Pull-On Tab
CHECK PRICE

Sloggers Women's Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoe with Comfort Insole, Midsummer Black, Size 9 Style 5102BK09

Sloggers Women’s Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoe with Comfort Insole
  • Made from 100% recyclable material
  • Includes “All-Day-Comfort” insoles
  • Heavy-duty lug tread
CHECK PRICE

Crocs Women's Jaunt Shorty Boot Rubber Wellington Boots Size 7 Black

Crocs Women’s Jaunt Shorty Boot
  • Expansive sizes
  • Lightweight
  • Insoles are replaceable
CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Men's Rubber Garden Shoes,Bark/Otter,7 M US

Muck Boot Muckster Ll Men’s Rubber Garden Shoes
  • Waterproof
  • 4mm Neoprene
  • Breathable air mesh inner-lining
CHECK PRICE
CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men's Rubber Garden Boots,Bark/Otter,10 M US

CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men's Rubber Garden Boots,Bark/Otter,10 M US

CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men's Rubber Garden Boots,Bark/Otter,10 M US

Features

  • 100% Waterproof
  • 4mm Neoprene Insulation
  • Easy On/Off with Pull-On Tab
  • Quick Cleaning Rubber Outsole
  • Breathable Mesh Lining
  • bioDEWIX Footbed Insert
  • Sub Freezing to 18°C/65°F

This muckster boot is a play on The Original Muck Boot Company’s best product but with updated outsole patterns and height. It is ideal to be used in places where there is wet, rain, slush, and mud. Therefore, making a garden the perfect place to use it. These boots are easy to slip on and quick to kick off along with having great breathability for comfortability.

WHAT WE LIKE

The construction of the boot is great: it has a contoured fit to help prevent blisters and chafing, a high-grade extended rubber overlay that creates a waterproof seal and protection, the outsole is made from high-traction rubber to make it slip-resistant, and breathable lining wicks away moisture and sweat.

The bioDEWIX Footbed Insert Top Cover is great for moisture and odor management, too. Sometimes rubber work shoes can be difficult to take on and off. However, these Mucksters were designed not only to have an easy kick-off feature but also have a pull tab on the back at the top to facilitate putting on and taking off the boot.

WHAT WE DONT LIKE

Beware when buying as the sizing runs small – order an entire size up if possible. While most of the boots arrive fine and stay functional, occasionally comes a pair where they arrive with a hole in the sole or the sole and boot itself fall apart due to use making it not waterproof.

PROS

  • Moisture and odor management
  • Slip-resistant
  • Breathable
  • 100% waterproof
  • Easy on/off

CONS

  • Sizing runs small
  • Holes in boot occasionally
CHECK PRICE

Sloggers Women's Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoe with Comfort Insole, Midsummer Black, Size 9 Style 5102BK09

CHECK PRICE

Sloggers Women's Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoe with Comfort Insole, Midsummer Black, Size 9 Style 5102BK09

CHECK PRICE

Sloggers Women's Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoe with Comfort Insole, Midsummer Black, Size 9 Style 5102BK09

Features

  • Made in the USA
  • Made from 100% recyclable material
  • Includes “All-Day-Comfort” insoles
  • Heavy-duty lug tread
  • Easy to clean
  • 100% waterproof

These women’s gardening shoes come in sizes 6-11 and in over ten different colors and patterns to fit not only any garden but also any outfit. They are made in the US and are designed to be comparable to the waterproof work boot without being clunky, bulky, or unappealing to the eye.

WHAT WE LIKE

When buying shoes online, ensuring that you are ordering the correct size can be tricky. Luckily, this company’s page offers an in-depth analysis of their size chart as well as guidelines for sizing. When it comes to recycling, these shoes are made from 100% recyclable material and the durable soles are made from 50% recycled material. They are easy to clean with a wet cloth and the insole is removable for cleaning, too.

WHAT WE DONT LIKE

With the heavy-duty greatness that is these shoes, that greatness comes with great weight. These shoes are heavy and when walking that weight can be felt. Along those same lines and due to the material on the outside, these shoes are not very breathable nor do they provide arch support on the inside.

PROS

  • Great online sizing chart
  • Vegan friendly, non-latex, 100% recyclable material
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable
  • Comfortable

CONS

  • Heavy 
  • Not very breathable
  • No arch support
CHECK PRICE

Crocs Women's Jaunt Shorty Boot Rubber Wellington Boots Size 7 Black

CHECK PRICE

Crocs Women's Jaunt Shorty Boot Rubber Wellington Boots Size 7 Black

CHECK PRICE

Crocs Women's Jaunt Shorty Boot Rubber Wellington Boots Size 7 Black

Features

  • Made from 100% synthetic materials
  • Sole made from Ethylene Vinyl Acetate
  • The shaft measures approximately 8″ from arch
  • The heel measures approximately 0.97″
  • Boot opening measures approximately 12.5″ around

Although this Crocs Shorty Boot was designed for a rainy day to be the lightest rain boots around, they also work wonderfully for gardening due to their material, shorty boot height, and their functionality. They come in two pretty colors – blue and black – and sizes ranging from four to eleven.

WHAT WE LIKE

Shoe sizing can be complicated – especially for really small or really big feet. Luckily, these boots come in size four to size eleven to fit every need. Some durable boots and gardening shoes are made from heavy-duty rubber and therefore weigh quite a lot; however, these are made from synthetic material which makes them durable and lightweight. The insoles can be taken out and replaced with the user’s preferred insoles for added comfort.

WHAT WE DONT LIKE

Crocs are known for coming in diverse colors and designs. However, this Shorty Boot comes in only two colors – black and navy blue. Since the boots were made for wet and colder weather, they end up shrinking in heat so it is essential not to leave them drying in the sun or expose them to the sun for long periods of time. Furthermore, they are not made for “wide feet”.

PROS

  • Expansive sizes
  • Lightweight
  • Insoles are replaceable

CONS

  • Comes in only two colors
  • Shrink in heat
  • Not made for wider feet
CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Men's Rubber Garden Shoes,Bark/Otter,7 M US

CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Men's Rubber Garden Shoes,Bark/Otter,7 M US

CHECK PRICE

Muckster ll Men's Rubber Garden Shoes,Bark/Otter,7 M US

Features

  • Waterproof
  • 4mm Neoprene
  • Breathable air mesh inner-lining
  • Very comfortable
  • High-traction rubber outsole
  • Slip-ons

If you are looking for good shoes to leave by the back door, these are ideal. They have high traction rubber outsoles which help with traction on wet surfaces and can easily shed debris or mud tracked in from the outside. Plus, they are easy-on-easy-off slip-on shoes.

WHAT WE LIKE

Having shoes that are easy to get on and off saves time and these shoes have a slip-on and easy kick-off design. They are incredibly comfortable due to the interior air mesh lining which is breathable so sweat and moisture are not an issue. It also is rated from below zero to 18ºC/65ºF comfortably. The outsole has high-grade rubber for durability and is 100% waterproof.

WHAT WE DONT LIKE

Although these shoes are great in many ways, they also only go up to below the ankle which means they do not provide ankle support or additional calf protection. When ordering, order a half-size or a whole-size up as the product line also tends to run small.

PROS

  • Slip-on and easy kick-off design
  • 100% waterproof
  • Breathable interior
  • Durable

CONS

  • No ankle support
  • No calf protection
  • The product runs small in size

FINAL VERDICT 

For the best gardening shoe for men, the ​​Muckster ll Ankle-Height Men’s Rubber Garden Boots takes the cake due to their comfort and durability.

Getting cold feet is never fun – especially when they are wet. Luckily, these rubber garden boots have a guaranteed comfort level from subzero temperatures to 18ºC/65ºF. Furthermore, being 100% waterproof guarantees that having wet feet will never be a problem. The 4mm of Neoprene insulation creates flexibility, overall comfort, and heat retention properties. 

In addition, it adjusts to the contours of the foot which prevents chafing and blisters. When it comes to durability, the quick cleaning rubber outsole offers durability and traction on slick surfaces making it slip-resistant. The outside also has a high-grade extended rubber overlay which is what creates 100% waterproof protection. On the inside, the 4mm of Neoprene insulation aids that 100% waterproofing along with shock absorption. The air mesh lining creates breathability that wicks away moisture and sweat. 

Although it was originally designed to be a rain boot, the best gardening shoe for women, the Crocs Women’s Jaunt Shorty Boot is the best choice on the list due to its durability and design. 

As a rain boot, it is made from synthetics which makes it also perfect to work in the garden due to the durability of the material. It is easy to wipe clean and is 100% waterproof. In fact, they are easy to rinse off when they get muddy, even after the mud dries for a few days. 

The design, unlike other gardening shoes, comes up above the ankle and protects the ankle and the pant leg which can easily get destroyed or muddied up in the garden. Plus, if the insoles are not comfortable, they are easy to take out and replace with insoles that feel better to walk in.

If you loved this post about the best gardening shoes, consider checking out these articles.

Free Companion Planting Chart

Hello! I’m Megan Gilger,

A strong believer that nature and the seasons are our greatest teachers. We live on a hill in Leelanau County, Michigan just a stone’s throw from Lake Michigan. This land we are responsible for is where we are focused on building a life around the seasons and intention. We spend our days here building a regenerative model of living and focusing our garden on native plants and intensive polyculture planting styles. My focus is less on self-sufficiency and more on community-sufficiency through how we grow and connect through the seasons.
Learn More